Troll or Not a Troll is a Drunken Peasants segment in which an "exceptionally out there" video is played, and the hosts as well as guests on the show vote to decide whether or not they believe it's a troll or for real. On a few occasions, this vote has resulted in a tie.
- The theme song was made by the same dude who created the song Ass Banana, Cory Cooper.
- Paul will often call it as either a Troll or not a Troll before the video begins.
- There was originally a strawpoll included in the description of each video for the audience. Eventually, they stopped bothering with the polls because people were voting before the video was even shown.
- The guy who made the "tie" animation is a fucking retard. You can see that he made it using PowerPoint, and that he doesn't know how to edit.